|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 11:31:16 GMT 10
Post by larry emdur is my hero! on Mar 11, 2003 11:31:16 GMT 10
not unlike nirvana... maybe theres a good reason that all the bands that sound like nirvana are really bad...... its because they have achieved it so well just like all these serious metal acts that end up sounding like same tool album over and over again.... |
|
MARK!
captain
Viva Emptiness
Posts: 528
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 14:46:23 GMT 10
Post by MARK! on Mar 11, 2003 14:46:23 GMT 10
just like all these serious metal acts that end up sounding like same tool album over and over again.... don't know anyone whose made an album that sounds like a tool album... though if they did congratulations to them cause it would actually take some talent to do so....... |
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 20:27:18 GMT 10
Post by Tiberius on Mar 11, 2003 20:27:18 GMT 10
Having an influence (or influences) is one thing. I was listening to some Fugazi the other day and was remembering how Paul said they were influence for him. I could hear the somethingforkateness in some of the Fugazi guitar work and could see how it was an influence for Paul. And that's not a bad thing. Something For Kate's music may be influenced by Fugazi but it's not a copy, and that's what the question is. It’s just, where do you draw the line between being influenced and blanket plagiarism? Silverchair in their early days did look and sound a little like Nirvana jr (as people said back then too), but I'd say that these days Silverchair (for better or worse) have established their own sound and style different to Nirvana.
|
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 20:29:41 GMT 10
Post by Lounge Act on Mar 11, 2003 20:29:41 GMT 10
ww sounds similar to turkish disco by fugazi
|
|
Jerry
beautiful shark
Posts: 287
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 21:44:01 GMT 10
Post by Jerry on Mar 11, 2003 21:44:01 GMT 10
was that throwout to stay away intentional ;D yeah and you're the only one that noticed  |
|
MARK!
captain
Viva Emptiness
Posts: 528
|
NIRVANA
Mar 11, 2003 22:25:38 GMT 10
Post by MARK! on Mar 11, 2003 22:25:38 GMT 10
It’s just, where do you draw the line between being influenced and blanket plagiarism? Silverchair in their early days did look and sound a little like Nirvana jr......... well i do think that frogstomp had its fair bit of plaigarism... many recycled songs there..... leave me out being the most notable |
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 7:54:09 GMT 10
Post by fathershark on Mar 12, 2003 7:54:09 GMT 10
come on - as if that counts. They were just KIDS when frogstomp was released....
|
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 10:20:22 GMT 10
Post by Firecracker on Mar 12, 2003 10:20:22 GMT 10
don't know anyone whose made an album that sounds like a tool album... though if they did congratulations to them cause it would actually take some talent to do so... Agreed. |
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 13:18:48 GMT 10
Post by Heading East on Mar 12, 2003 13:18:48 GMT 10
Yes i agree with you Katy, finding a band like that however, is rare, but bands like kyuss, qotsa and tool break the mould. I dont like it, but most avenues of music have been tapped, its a lot harder to create something new these days. And as for eddievedders comment on metal bands repeating tool albums, thats bloody difficult, cos they have a style all of their own *points to avatar of adam jones*
|
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 13:27:51 GMT 10
Post by fathershark on Mar 12, 2003 13:27:51 GMT 10
The most diverse AND original musical act that I can think of from within the last decade is of course: FAITH NO MORE.
You could have a directory the size of a phone book listing all of the music styles which they dipped into in their almost 20 years together - each of which they dud well.
I know most of you will know the band from their 1990 single "epic", but I found their later work to be much more pioneering - songs such as "Just a Man", "Jizzlobber", "Naked in front of the Computer", and "Strip Search".
Nooch.
|
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 16:11:41 GMT 10
Post by Firecracker on Mar 12, 2003 16:11:41 GMT 10
Faith No More changed me.
|
|
|
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 18:21:38 GMT 10
Post by TheAstronaut on Mar 12, 2003 18:21:38 GMT 10
I found that Ashes to Ashes was the song that I first experienced from this band, and up until last year, I hadn't heard it for nearly 3-4 years. Theyre quite a good band, I should put some effort into their music.
If i were to say any band which I feel would be a great musical influence, it would either go to Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin. Page and Plant did some amazing work together, especially with the Middle-Eastern efforts of No Quarter, which is an amazing CD. Pink Floyd, however, changed music over their decades of performing, with oddities from Colonel Clegg to Keep talking ( my fave PF song). Syd Barrett....what a man! Went insane due to drugs, his songs are so strange. My friend Steven ( a huge PF fan) and I leeched off Kazaa some of Syd's songs - effervescent elephant, birdie hop, what a shame mary jane and scream thy lasy scream.
|
|
MARK!
captain
Viva Emptiness
Posts: 528
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 21:03:29 GMT 10
Post by MARK! on Mar 12, 2003 21:03:29 GMT 10
come on - as if that counts. They were just KIDS when frogstomp was released.... childredn are taught about plaigarism form year 7 or earlier  |
|
MARK!
captain
Viva Emptiness
Posts: 528
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 21:05:20 GMT 10
Post by MARK! on Mar 12, 2003 21:05:20 GMT 10
Yes i agree with you Katy, finding a band like that however, is rare, but bands like kyuss, qotsa and tool break the mould. I dont like it, but most avenues of music have been tapped, its a lot harder to create something new these days. And as for eddievedders comment on metal bands repeating tool albums, thats bloody difficult, cos they have a style all of their own *points to avatar of adam jones* hmmmm.... i have mixed opinions on QOTSa... but i think kyuss and tool were probably the 2 most revolutionary bands of the 90s  |
|
MARK!
captain
Viva Emptiness
Posts: 528
|
NIRVANA
Mar 12, 2003 21:08:03 GMT 10
Post by MARK! on Mar 12, 2003 21:08:03 GMT 10
The most diverse AND original musical act that I can think of from within the last decade is of course: FAITH NO MORE. You could have a directory the size of a phone book listing all of the music styles which they dipped into in their almost 20 years together - each of which they dud well. I know most of you will know the band from their 1990 single "epic", but I found their later work to be much more pioneering - songs such as "Just a Man", "Jizzlobber", "Naked in front of the Computer", and "Strip Search". Nooch. not much of an album of the year fan myself...... as i like to brag about i've been a fan since i was 5 and the real thing and angel dust are my favs.... definitely agree about them being so diverse.... though everything mike patton does rules |
|
